Will I Be Disinherited If I Challenge the Will?

Most wills and trusts contain a provision that says something like this: “If any beneficiary hereunder shall attack this last will and testament, such beneficiary’s share shall be thereby revoked and such beneficiary shall receive nothing” or “If anyone shall challenge this document, I leave such person $1.00.” This type of clause is known as a “no contest” or “in terrorem” clause; the latter is Latin meaning to frighten someone. In other words, the person making the will or trust includes this clause in order to scare beneficiaries or would-be beneficiaries from initiating a legal challenge or contest to the will or trust.

Are no contest clauses actually enforceable? In Nevada, they are enforceable, but with some significant caveats. First, no heir will be disinherited for asking a court to enforce the terms of the will, or enforcing that person’s legal rights under the will or trust. Moreover, it is perfectly legitimate for an heir to petition the court for instructions with respect to how the will should be interpreted. Second, regardless of the no contest clause, an heir who, in good faith, has probable cause to believe that the will was invalid, may bring an action challenging the will without fear of being disinherited, provided that he or she meets the standards set forth in Nevada’s probate code.

Does this defeat the intention of the person who made the will? Hopefully not. No contest clauses are designed to threaten family members who got less than their “fair” share—for example, where someone is intentionally omitted or got less than his brothers or sisters. The trouble is that if no one could legally challenge a will without being disinherited, then many families would be out of luck in situations involving undue influence. For example, a caretaker or perhaps a girlfriend or recently acquired spouse may unduly influence a sick or dying person, swaying or even coercing the susceptible testator to execute a will leaving nothing to family members. Nevada’s law on no contest clauses is intended to balance the interests of those who are of sound mind and memory and want to give uneven shares to their family members with the interests of those who are sick and susceptible to undue influence when they execute their wills.

If you have questions, you should contact a qualified Nevada probate attorney.

By Sharon M. Parker, Esq.

2 responses to “Will I Be Disinherited If I Challenge the Will?

  1. I love nvplanningandprobate.woodburnlaw.com! Here I always find a lot of helpful information for myself. Thanks you for your work.
    Webmaster of http://loveepicentre.com and http://movieszone.eu
    Best regards

  2. That was a really interesting read about Will I Be Disinherited If I Challenge the Will? | Nevada Estate Planning and Probate

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s